image by Brad Folkens
After interviewing musicians, we at detone8.com ask for one piece of advice they would give a new band. Often, that advice is watching out for creative differences.
Creative differences is a nice way of saying, “we don’t like playing in this band anymore.” It can be a necessary tool in growing as a musician, but it can also destroy a promising band.
“If people don’t have a passion for the music it tears bands apart,” Steve Reter from Drop Out Year warned. “I have seen so many bands who have come and gone.”
Reter has been a part of Dropout Year for over five years. He started out as the bands personal manager, but as the band went through numerous lineups he added stability by becoming the singer.
According to Reter, success is a hard thing to keep up on, but it is the most rewarding things he has ever done. The way Dropout Year fights the never-ending battle against creative differences is by having a common thread that ties the band together. All of the members have individual influences, but they all have a similar style of punk rock they all listen to and want to play.
Even if a band of great musicians come together, there is no guarantee against the threat of creative differences. If the band loves the music, but no one else seems to care, the love can turn sour.
“Musicians play a crappy show and no one shows up,” Jesse Barnes from The Actress Adorable said. “They play 13 more shows and no one shows up and they quit.”
Barnes has seen talented musicians create great bands, but when they spend no time promoting and marketing their band the lack of interest becomes demoralizing. “They take shortcuts and it is a mistake,” Barnes said.
Creative differences will unravel a band without a solid foundation. Joe Bird, a founder of Quickstar Productions, has seen countless band come and go.
Quickstar Productions is a distribution company that helps unsigned bands get their music sold on iTunes or MySpace. But, even the bands with huge potential can fall to creative differences when the band members don’t have the same commitment.
At 17-years-old, Bird was in a band touring with and opening for major label bands. Bird has been in many other bands, but he said that he felt that band had a great chance of making it big. Yet, the band broke up after a short time.
“I didn’t take it seriously,” Bird said.
Bird warns to watch out for band members that consistently fail the band. If the band starts having issues and they don’t get fixed, start looking for new members.
Ways to avoid creative differences
- Don’t write what’s popular now- For more than five years Dropout Year has built up a solid line up of punk songs based on a love for the music. Even with all the different styles of music the members listen to, every member is dedicated to punk rock. Is what you’re playing now what you will like playing in five years?
- Work with a producer- Even if it is just a friend, another person’s honest opinions can bring stale music back to life. Jesse Barnes of the Actress Adorable suggests talking with local bands you like and see whom they are working with.
- Remove bad elements- When one member of a band is less dedicated than the others, it will drag everyone else down. Joe Bird suggests giving the member a chance to change. If the person fails to deliver a second time it is time to find someone new.